Should i weed or seed a poor lawn

Should I seed my lawn in Spring or Fall?

Seeding in Spring or Fall? A common question from homeowners.

One common question I am asked every Spring is, “Should I seed my lawn in Spring or Fall?” Many homeowners are eager to start thickening up their lawn as soon as they get a glimpse of good weather in early Spring. We sometimes still have a late March snow on the ground when the calls start coming in. My answer to their question is the ever-popular “It depends.” After explaining the pros and cons to many homeowners over the years, I’ve put my recommendation in writing on this page.

When is the best time to seed my Northern Illinois lawn?

Per the Illinois Department of Agriculture resources and many other university studies, the best time to seed in Northern Illinois is either Spring (the month of April), or early Fall (late August through the 2nd week of September). I am going to make it easier for you and recommend that you stick with early fall. Keep reading to find out why…

Seeding your lawn in Spring

Spring is a great time to seed your lawn, but there are more cons than pros when it comes to seeding this time of year. There are 2 main reasons why you should not seed your lawn in Spring: pre-emergent and summer.


As part of a normal lawn care program, pre-emergent is usually applied in the Spring to help prevent crabgrass and many other types of weeds. That is the good part about pre-emergent. The bad part about pre-emergent is, it also prevents good grass seed from germinating. If you put seed down all over your yard and then a pre-emergent is applied over the top of it, chances are, the seed will not germinate, or will experience a very low germination rate.


Grass plants depend on deep, healthy roots, and a tall, thick stand of grass blades to help it survive the stresses of Summer. Deep roots allow the grass to reach moisture that lies beyond the dried out top layer of soil. A tall and thick stand of grass blades help to shade the soil and prevent weeds from competing with the lawn. When you seed in the Spring, the new grass plants may come up very nicely after a few weeks, but under the soil, the roots will not yet be deep enough to survive Summer without a significant amount of irrigation from a sprinkler system. Unless you keep the seedlings watered all summer long and into early Fall, the chances of their survival is slim to none.

Seeding your lawn in Early Fall

If you seed your lawn in early Fall, the seedlings will have 9 to 10 months to develop deeper root systems before they have to experience their first Summer of hot and dry weather. Compare this to 1 or 2 months for a Spring seeding, and the chances of an early Fall seeding surviving to maturity are significantly greater. On top of that, you can still apply your pre-emergent in Spring and keep out the crabgrass and other weeds throughout the season.

Exceptions to my seeding recommendation

As with any rule or recommendation, there are always exceptions. For example, you may want to seed in the Spring if you had extensive drought or grub damage during the previous summer or fall. Pre-emergent works best on a thick stand of turf, but it does not work well in areas where there is exposed soil and not much grass. In cases like this, you have to compare the pros and cons. If you have a lot of bare spots, and you wait until Fall to seed, you may end up with a lot more weeds in those bare spots throughout the season. If you skip the pre-emergent and seed the bare areas in the Spring, you will prevent a lot of weeds in those bare areas, but you might experience some crabgrass or other weeds throughout the lawn.

Lawn seeding recommendation summary

To summarize, follow these recommendations when seeding your lawn in Northern Illinois:

Repair prior year damage or bare spots in Spring (month of April)

  • Apply pre-emergent for crabgrass and other weeds as part of your regular lawn care program.
  • Fix bare spots by roughing them up with a garden rake and adding fresh top soil and seed.
  • Keep the seeded areas and new seedlings watered throughout the Summer.

Over-seed the entire lawn in Early Fall (late August through early September)

    the entire lawn.
  • Over-seed the entire lawn.
  • You can also repair summer damage this time of year.

If you need any assistance with lawn care, core aeration, and over-seeding, please fill out the form on this page and I can provide you with a free quote and answer any other questions you might have.

Should You Reseed or Re-sod Your Lawn?

If your lawn is in rough shape, you may be wondering what the best course of action is to restore your lawn to a green and healthy state. There are a few factors to consider when deciding whether you should reseed or resod your lawn. Both options have their own set of advantages and disadvantages that should be considered.

Evaluate the Condition on Your Lawn

The first step is evaluating your current lawn condition. Carefully examine the lawn for weeds, undesirable grass, disease and any damage. As a general rule of thumb, if your lawn is over 50% weeds it might be best to renovate your lawn and start over with new sod. If your lawn is less than 50% weeds, putting in the effort to restore your lawn by overseeding may be worthwhile.

You should also conduct a soil test to determine the availability of essential nutrients within your lawn. If your soil lacks nutrients, you may need to amend your soil with fertilizer, compost or other organic materials. Having a good base for your grass to grow is crucial for a dense, healthy turf. After evaluating your turf, consider the advantages and disadvantages associated with each.

Advantages of Resodding

Instant results: While the lawn may not be ready for foot traffic, it immediately improves curb appeal and gives your home a finished look.

Few weeds: High-quality sod should have very few weeds and be strong enough to outcompete any that try to emerge.

Quick establishment: With consistent watering, your sod should be well-established within 2 to 3 weeks. This means your backyard will be ready for entertaining, pets and kids.

Disadvantages of Resodding

Costly: New sod is more expensive than purchasing grass seed.

Labor intensive: Installing new sod can be hard work and must be done correctly. If you’re less experienced, you may want to consider contacting a professional.

Advantages of Reseeding

Less expensive: High-quality grass seed is less expensive than purchasing sod.

Easier to complete: Overseeding your lawn is a simpler process than sodding and requires overall less labor-intensive work.

Disadvantages of Reseeding

Weed competition: New grass seedlings have to compete with weeds for sunlight, nutrients and light.

Longer establishment period: Sod can establish itself much faster. New seed can take up to 10 weeks before it is well-established and ready for foot traffic.

Long-term results: While new sod can quickly transform your yard, reseeding can take a full growing season for new grass to appear dense, lush and green.

Whether you decide on resodding or reseeding your lawn, it is important that you keep up with regular maintenance including watering, fertilizing and proper mowing. Lawn care is a long-term and ongoing process that takes time, patience and commitment! If you ever have questions regarding the health or condition of your turf, please do not hesitate to contact Weed Man, we would be more than happy to help!

Brought to you by Weed Man Lawn Care: we care for your lawn.